Cross-Cultural Semiotic Representations in Online Dating: A Comparative Analysis of Male and Female Non-Verbal Cues on Muzz and Tinder Platforms

Abstract

Semiotics remains vital for decoding cultural representations, including digital spaces like dating platforms, where identity is constructed through visual and symbolic elements. However, comparative studies between faith-based and secular platforms using semiotics are few to none. This study bridges this gap by analyzing how users on Muzz (Islamic-focused) and Tinder (secular) employ non-verbal visual strategies to craft culturally appropriate identities.Using a qualitative comparative approach, we integrate Lotman'ssemiosphere theory and Barthes' denotation and connotation framework to examine twenty purposively selected profiles (balanced by platform and gender). The research investigates how cultural values manifest through visual semiotic strategies and examines denotative and connotative meanings embedded within users' self-presentation choices.The findings show that both platforms use similar visual elements like clothing and backgrounds, but these carry different cultural meanings. On Muzz, formal attire signals traditional provider roles and religious commitment, while the same clothing on Tinder represents lifestyle sophistication. Religious symbols appear exclusively on Muzz profiles, with hijabs and Mecca photographs communicating spiritual identity, whereas Tinder users display tattoos and body modifications as expressions of individual emancipation.Users adapt their self-presentation strategies to match each platform's cultural expectations while maintaining authentic identity expression. This research contributes to digital cultural semiotics by providing the first systematic comparative analysis of faith-based versus secular dating platforms, establishing methodological frameworks for future cross-cultural digital communication studies